火球法师
精华
|
战斗力 鹅
|
回帖 0
注册时间 2011-4-2
|
转自姐妹论坛
看到外粉讨论为何白毛的PP值那么纯洁，dominator无法定义他是潜在犯，觉得很有道理。
My speculation is that Makishima simply feels no emotion from the act of hurting or killing. It\\'s not a net zero from subtracting sadism from empathy, like how it usually is. It\\'s zero from the start.
Criminals enjoy the act of killing; there\\'s lots of ways this happens. If a criminal is stressed and a victim is the root of that stress, killing the victim gives the criminal the "enjoyment" of releasing that stress. If the criminal is Oryo Rikako, the process of killing is itself the entertainment. If the criminal is Toyohisa Senguji, the hunt provides the entertainment. All of these involve the pain/death of others as the direct source of enjoyment. Let\\'s call an individual\\'s willingness to do this "sadism".
Normally, everyone has a certain level of sadism in them (bear with me here ). But they also have a latent value of "empathy" that counteracts that sadism. For the sake of simplicity, let\\'s let the difference between those two variables determine how likely someone will commit crimes.
Now consider Makishima\\'s philosophy. Apparently he just wants other people to "be themselves". Whether or not this entails people dying is of no concern to him. He\\'s never interested in watching the murders, he\\'s only interested in the person doing the murders. What he did this episode is the same thing. He does not enjoy killing Yuki. He does not even enjoy watching Akane squirm (and is even disappointed at that). He just wants to test people.
In a regular situation, this is still fine; in fact, it\\'s optimal because someone who does not enjoy hurting/killing would have a sadism value of zero. Then empathy would naturally dominate.
And thus comes the catch: what if an individual\\'s empathy is also zero? Then this test is inconclusive. That\\'s what I see Makishima as.
总结这段来说就是dominator测试的是人由于犯罪（伤害，虐待，杀戮）产生的快感，或精神兴奋脑波。大部分罪犯犯罪的动机无外乎愉悦犯罪和释压犯罪。愉悦犯罪不必说，即使是看似逼不得已的犯罪，比如仇杀，防卫自身等，也会在强大的压力解除的瞬间由于轻松产生兴奋感或快感。
之前外粉有讨论dominator的瑕疵在于只能检举出psycho path而检举不出socio path，白毛是socio path，因为不被认证。但这个论点在王陵的例子上就已经站不住脚了（王陵显然也是socio path，但PP值很高）。相对我认为测试犯罪兴奋度这个理论比较合理。白毛和王陵都是看似无比冷静的计划犯罪，但王陵有极高的PP值，原因就是在于她享受杀戮分尸造成的快感（或许不是一种肉体的快感而只是因为自我欣赏和极度自恋产生的精神快感），而白毛没有任何称之为快感的东西。这大概也是白毛对王陵失望的原因——她太沉浸在自以为是的小世界里了。 |
|
楼主: 子戏星斋
沪公网安备 31010702007642号 )
发表于 2012-12-21 19:25
老虚你看看你
......突然在想那个世界是不是同性恋也会导致pp值升高
也许接下来女主发现自己是和白毛一样的特例
”这个人必须被惩罚！“
？？
